Skip to main content

Content Writer Analysis

Overview​

Content Writer Analysis is the systematic evaluation of content creators' performance, writing quality, SEO effectiveness, and impact on business goals to identify strengths, improvement areas, and optimize content team output.

What is Content Writer Analysis?​

Content Writer Analysis involves:

  • Performance evaluation of individual writers
  • Quality assessment of written content
  • SEO effectiveness measurement
  • Business impact tracking
  • Skill development identification

Why Content Writer Analysis Matters​

  • Quality Improvement: Identify and address weak areas
  • Team Optimization: Match writers to appropriate topics
  • ROI Tracking: Connect writing to business outcomes
  • Training Focus: Guide professional development
  • Process Improvement: Refine workflows and standards

Key Metrics for Writer Analysis​

1. Content Quality Metrics​

Readability Scores:

  • Flesch Reading Ease (target: 60-70)
  • Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level (target: 8th grade)
  • Average sentence length
  • Average word length

Writing Quality:

  • Grammar and spelling errors
  • Clarity and coherence
  • Tone consistency
  • Brand voice adherence

Content Depth:

  • Topic coverage completeness
  • Research quality
  • Original insights
  • Use of examples and data

2. SEO Performance Metrics​

On-Page Optimization:

  • Keyword usage appropriateness
  • Title tag optimization
  • Meta description quality
  • Header structure
  • Internal linking

Search Rankings:

  • Average position for target keywords
  • Number of keywords ranking
  • Featured snippet wins
  • Page 1 rankings

Organic Traffic:

  • Sessions per article
  • Average time on page
  • Bounce rate
  • Pages per session

3. Engagement Metrics​

User Behavior:

  • Average time on page
  • Scroll depth percentage
  • Click-through rate
  • Social shares
  • Comments

Conversion Metrics:

  • Lead generation rate
  • Email sign-ups
  • Product page visits
  • Purchase attribution

4. Efficiency Metrics​

Production Speed:

  • Time from assignment to draft
  • Average revision rounds
  • Words per hour
  • Articles completed per week

Editorial Efficiency:

  • First-draft acceptance rate
  • Number of edits required
  • Meeting deadlines
  • Brief adherence

Content Analysis Framework​

1. Individual Article Analysis​

Content Brief Compliance:

  • ✓ Target keyword usage
  • ✓ Required word count
  • ✓ Subtopics covered
  • ✓ Tone and style
  • ✓ Required elements (images, lists, tables)

SEO Checklist:

  • ✓ Title optimization
  • ✓ Meta description
  • ✓ Header hierarchy
  • ✓ Internal links (3-5)
  • ✓ External authority links (2-3)
  • ✓ Image alt text
  • ✓ URL optimization

Quality Assessment:

  • ✓ No grammar/spelling errors
  • ✓ Clear and logical flow
  • ✓ Accurate information
  • ✓ Engaging introduction
  • ✓ Strong conclusion
  • ✓ Actionable takeaways

2. Writer Portfolio Analysis​

Content Performance Summary:

  • Total articles published
  • Average organic traffic per article
  • Best-performing pieces
  • Worst-performing pieces
  • Specialty topics

Skill Assessment:

  • Writing strengths
  • Areas for improvement
  • Content type expertise
  • Industry knowledge
  • SEO proficiency

3. Comparative Analysis​

Peer Benchmarking:

  • Performance vs team average
  • Quality scores comparison
  • Speed comparison
  • Specialization identification

Analysis Methods​

1. Quantitative Analysis​

Tools and Data Sources:

  • Google Analytics (traffic, engagement)
  • Google Search Console (rankings, CTR)
  • SEO tools (Ahrefs, SEMrush)
  • CMS analytics (publication data)
  • Grammarly/Hemingway (quality scores)

Data Collection:

Writer Performance Spreadsheet:
- Writer Name
- Article Title
- Publication Date
- Word Count
- Time to Complete
- Target Keyword
- Current Ranking
- Monthly Traffic
- Avg. Time on Page
- Bounce Rate
- Conversions
- Social Shares

2. Qualitative Analysis​

Editorial Review:

  • Content relevance
  • Originality and insight
  • Storytelling quality
  • Example effectiveness
  • Call-to-action strength

Expert Review:

  • Subject matter accuracy
  • Industry terminology usage
  • Best practice adherence
  • Innovation and uniqueness

3. User Feedback​

Direct Feedback:

  • Comments analysis
  • Email responses
  • Social media reactions
  • Customer service mentions

Surveys:

  • Content satisfaction ratings
  • Helpfulness scores
  • Likelihood to recommend
  • Content format preferences

Writer Performance Dashboard​

Monthly Writer Scorecard​

Productivity:

  • Articles published: 8
  • Total words: 18,000
  • Average article length: 2,250 words
  • On-time delivery: 100%

Quality:

  • Average readability score: 68
  • Edits required per article: 1.2
  • Grammar errors per 1,000 words: 0.5
  • Brief compliance: 95%

SEO Performance:

  • Average keyword ranking: Position 8
  • Featured snippets earned: 2
  • Page 1 rankings: 12 keywords
  • Average organic traffic: 450/month per article

Engagement:

  • Average time on page: 4:32
  • Bounce rate: 58%
  • Social shares: 45
  • Comments: 12

Business Impact:

  • Leads generated: 23
  • Attributed revenue: $12,000
  • ROI: 8:1

Analysis Tools and Resources​

Writing Quality Tools​

Grammarly:

  • Grammar and spelling checks
  • Tone analysis
  • Clarity suggestions
  • Plagiarism detection

Hemingway Editor:

  • Readability scoring
  • Sentence complexity
  • Passive voice detection
  • Adverb usage

ProWritingAid:

  • Style suggestions
  • Overused words
  • Consistency checking
  • Pacing analysis

SEO Analysis Tools​

Surfer SEO:

  • Content scoring
  • Keyword density
  • Competitor comparison
  • On-page optimization

Clearscope:

  • Content grading
  • Topic coverage
  • Readability metrics

Yoast SEO:

  • On-page SEO check
  • Readability analysis
  • Internal linking suggestions

Performance Tracking​

Google Analytics:

  • Traffic by author
  • Engagement metrics
  • Conversion tracking

Google Search Console:

  • Ranking positions
  • Click-through rates
  • Search impressions

Ahrefs/SEMrush:

  • Keyword rankings
  • Backlinks earned
  • Competitor comparison

Conducting Writer Reviews​

Quarterly Review Process​

Week 1: Data Collection

  • Compile all metrics
  • Create performance reports
  • Identify patterns and trends

Week 2: Analysis

  • Review top performers
  • Identify improvement areas
  • Compare to benchmarks

Week 3: Review Meetings

  • One-on-one discussions
  • Share performance data
  • Set improvement goals
  • Plan training needs

Week 4: Action Planning

  • Create development plans
  • Assign new responsibilities
  • Adjust workloads
  • Update processes

Review Meeting Structure​

1. Performance Highlights (10 minutes)

  • Best-performing content
  • Achievements and wins
  • Positive feedback received

2. Metrics Review (15 minutes)

  • Traffic and rankings
  • Engagement data
  • Conversion performance
  • Quality scores

3. Growth Areas (10 minutes)

  • Areas for improvement
  • Skill gaps
  • Process challenges

4. Goal Setting (10 minutes)

  • Next quarter objectives
  • Training plan
  • New challenges
  • Resource needs

5. Questions and Discussion (15 minutes)

  • Writer concerns
  • Process improvements
  • Support needed

Writer Development Strategies​

Skill Improvement Areas​

Writing Quality:

  • Writing workshops
  • Peer review sessions
  • Style guide training
  • Advanced grammar courses

SEO Skills:

  • SEO certification courses
  • Keyword research training
  • Technical SEO basics
  • Content optimization workshops

Subject Matter Expertise:

  • Industry research time
  • Conference attendance
  • Expert interviews
  • Course enrollment

Efficiency:

  • Time management training
  • Template development
  • Research shortcuts
  • Writing sprints

Training Methods​

Formal Training:

  • Online courses (Coursera, LinkedIn Learning)
  • Certifications (HubSpot, Google)
  • Workshops and seminars
  • Conference attendance

Informal Learning:

  • Peer mentorship
  • Article reviews
  • Best practice sharing
  • Case study analysis

Practice and Feedback:

  • Writing exercises
  • A/B testing content
  • Editor collaboration
  • Client feedback incorporation

Common Writer Issues and Solutions​

Issue: Inconsistent Quality​

Analysis:

  • Review quality scores over time
  • Identify pattern in poor performers
  • Check workload and deadlines

Solutions:

  • Provide detailed briefs
  • Implement quality checklist
  • Add peer review step
  • Reduce article volume temporarily

Issue: Low SEO Performance​

Analysis:

  • Review keyword research process
  • Check competitor content
  • Analyze on-page optimization

Solutions:

  • SEO training sessions
  • Provide SEO checklists
  • Use content optimization tools
  • Pair with SEO specialist

Issue: Slow Production​

Analysis:

  • Track time per article stage
  • Identify bottlenecks
  • Review writer workload

Solutions:

  • Create templates
  • Improve research process
  • Adjust deadlines
  • Provide better briefs

Issue: Low Engagement​

Analysis:

  • Review content topics
  • Check writing style
  • Analyze user feedback

Solutions:

  • Research audience needs
  • Study high-performing content
  • Experiment with formats
  • Add multimedia elements

Writer Specialization​

Identifying Strengths​

Content Type Expertise:

  • Long-form guides
  • How-to tutorials
  • Case studies
  • Product reviews
  • Technical documentation

Topic Expertise:

  • Industry knowledge
  • Technical subjects
  • Creative writing
  • Data-driven content

Audience Expertise:

  • B2B decision makers
  • Technical audiences
  • General consumers
  • Specific demographics

Assignment Optimization​

Match Writers to Strengths:

  • Assign based on performance data
  • Consider topic expertise
  • Respect preferences
  • Allow growth opportunities

Content Distribution:

  • 70% in strength areas
  • 20% in development areas
  • 10% experimental/stretch assignments

Red Flags to Watch​

⚠️ Performance Warning Signs:

  • Consistent missed deadlines
  • Declining quality scores
  • Increasing revision needs
  • Negative feedback patterns
  • Disengagement signals

⚠️ Content Quality Issues:

  • Plagiarism or heavy reliance on sources
  • Factual errors
  • Brand voice violations
  • SEO over-optimization
  • Thin or shallow content

Best Practices​

  1. Regular Reviews: Conduct quarterly formal reviews
  2. Continuous Feedback: Provide ongoing constructive feedback
  3. Data-Driven: Base assessments on metrics, not opinions
  4. Balanced Approach: Consider both quality and quantity
  5. Development Focus: Emphasize growth over criticism
  6. Clear Standards: Document expectations and criteria
  7. Recognition: Celebrate wins and improvements
  8. Support: Provide resources for improvement

Creating a Writer Scorecard​

Monthly Scorecard Template​

Writer: [Name] Period: [Month/Year]

Production (Weight: 20%):

  • Articles completed: [#] / [Target]
  • Words produced: [#]
  • On-time delivery: [%]

Quality (Weight: 30%):

  • Readability score: [#]
  • Edits per article: [#]
  • Brief compliance: [%]
  • First-draft acceptance: [%]

SEO Performance (Weight: 30%):

  • Avg. ranking position: [#]
  • Keywords ranking: [#]
  • Traffic per article: [#]
  • Featured snippets: [#]

Business Impact (Weight: 20%):

  • Engagement rate: [%]
  • Leads generated: [#]
  • Conversion rate: [%]

Overall Score: [#/100]

Further Reading​